Sunset over the Great South Bay, the water the Fire Island ferries cross from Bay Shore

Bay Shore Car Service


To the boats

Bay Shore to the Fire Island Ferries

Fire Island Ferries runs from Maple Avenue in Bay Shore to eight western Fire Island communities. We drive you to the dock, bags and all:

From 99 Maple Avenue, Bay Shore

  • Kismet
  • Saltaire
  • Fair Harbor
  • Atlantique
  • Dunewood
  • Ocean Beach
  • Seaview
  • Ocean Bay Park

“A thirty minute ferry from Bay Shore,” in the ferry company’s own words.

55 min–1 h 40JFK to the ferry dock at 2 p.m.

1 h 30–3 h 30Times Square to the dock at 2 p.m.

22–35 minMacArthur to the dock at 2 p.m.

Drive times

Bay Shore Drive Times, From the Ferry Dock

These readings start at the ferry terminal on Maple Avenue. MacArthur is about 12 miles, typically 18–22 min at 5 a.m.; JFK about 33 miles, typically 40–55 min.

Drive times between Bay Shore and the airports and Manhattan, Google Maps typical ranges
To or fromMilesLeave Bay Shore 5 a.m.Leave Bay Shore 2 p.m.Back at 2 p.m.Back at 9 p.m.
MacArthur Airport (ISP)1218–22 min20–28 min22–35 min20–28 min
JFK Airport3340–55 min45 min–1 h 555 min–1 h 4040–55 min
LaGuardia Airport4350 min–1 h 1050 min–1 h 151 h–1 h 5050 min–1 h 5
Times Square, Manhattan481 h 5–1 h 401 h 20–2 h 101 h 30–3 h 301 h 5–1 h 40

When to leave Bay Shore

Leave Bay Shore for JFK: quickest start 3 a.m., typically 35–45 min; slowest 5 p.m., typically 55 min–1 h 25. Leave JFK for Bay Shore: quickest start 4 or 5 a.m., typically 35–50 min; slowest 4 p.m., typically 1 h 10–2 h 10.

Leave Bay Shore for JFK: Google’s fastest route ran via Southern State Parkway at 3 a.m. to 6 a.m., 10 a.m. to 3 p.m., 6 p.m. to 9 p.m.; via Ocean Parkway west at 7 a.m. to 9 a.m., 4 p.m. to 5 p.m. Leave JFK for Bay Shore: Google’s fastest route ran via Southern State Parkway at 3 a.m. to 2 p.m., 5 p.m. to 9 p.m.; via Ocean Parkway east at 3 p.m. to 4 p.m.

Show every hour
Hour by hour, Google Maps typical ranges for Wednesday 4 November 2026, Bay Shore
Start atLeave Bay Shore for JFKLeave JFK for Bay Shore
3 a.m.35–45 min40–50 min
4 a.m.35–45 min35–50 min
5 a.m.40–55 min35–50 min
6 a.m.45 min–1 h 1540–55 min
7 a.m.50 min–1 h 1045 min–1 h 15
8 a.m.50 min–1 h 1055 min–1 h 30
9 a.m.50 min–1 h 545 min–1 h 10
10 a.m.40 min–1 h40 min–1 h
11 a.m.40 min–1 h40 min–1 h
noon40 min–1 h40 min–1 h
1 p.m.40 min–1 h45 min–1 h 10
2 p.m.45 min–1 h 555 min–1 h 40
3 p.m.45 min–1 h 201 h 5–2 h 10
4 p.m.55 min–1 h 201 h 10–2 h 10
5 p.m.55 min–1 h 251 h 10–2 h
6 p.m.55 min–1 h 251 h–1 h 40
7 p.m.45 min–1 h50 min–1 h 10
8 p.m.40–55 min45 min–1 h
9 p.m.40–55 min40–55 min

One flat rate. Gratuity, tax and card fees are included; tolls and congestion pricing for your route are added before you confirm. Meet and greet is available as an add-on. No surprises, never surged.

Free waiting. 15 minutes’ grace at non-airport pickups. At airports, 45 minutes after a domestic landing and 60 after an international one, measured from the flight’s actual arrival.

Google Maps “typically” ranges from the Fire Island Ferries terminal, 99 Maple Avenue, on the fastest route for Wednesday 4 November 2026, read 29 October to 7 November 2026; miles are Google’s road miles at 2 p.m., and summer weekends are not in these readings.

Around Bay Shore

Where We Pick Up in Bay Shore

The ferry terminal

Fire Island Ferries, 99 Maple Avenue. Dock drop-offs are timed to the boat, with room for bags and the walk to the slip.

Bay Shore station

On the LIRR’s Montauk Branch; the MTA lists it as accessible, with ramps. We meet the train and take you to the dock or home.

Main Street

Restaurants and shops on Main Street are everyday pickups.

Waiting for the boat

Reserve the afternoon by the hour, three hours minimum, and the car holds until you sail.

On the line

Bay Shore station sits between Babylon and Islip on the Montauk Branch, by the railroad’s own schedule data.

Three gates on Maple Avenue

Fire Island Ferries lists the Main Terminal at Gate 1, 99 Maple Avenue, the West Terminal at Gate 2, 104 Maple Avenue, and the Saltaire Terminal at Gate 3. Tell us the gate for your boat and the chauffeur drops you there.

Sagtikos Manor, the county park and the Boulton Center

Sagtikos Manor, 677 Montauk Highway

Suffolk County’s Sagtikos Manor once ran from the Great South Bay to the middle of Long Island at Brentwood: 1,200 acres whose outline looked like the head of a snake, which is what the Indian name Sagtikos describes, the county says. Among the house’s 18th-century additions is the room where George Washington slept on his 1790 tour of Long Island. Robert David Lion Gardiner, who inherited the estate in 1935, began opening the house to the public, the Sagtikos Historic Society was formed in 1964 to give tours, and the manor joined the National Register in 1976.

Gardiner County Park

On land first owned by the Gardiner family, Suffolk’s first non-native landowners, and later part of the Sagtikos estate, Gardiner County Park keeps 231 acres on the Great South Bay for nature trails, bird watching and a dog park. Its entrance is south of Montauk Highway (Route 27A), about half a mile east of the Robert Moses Causeway.

The Boulton Center, 37 West Main Street

The Boulton Center seats 260 and puts on more than 100 shows a year: concerts, tribute nights, comedy, community nights and classic films. For an evening there, reserve the car by the hour and it waits nearby until the show ends.

Sources: Fire Island Ferries, LIRR schedule data (GTFS) (read 3 November 2026); MTA, Bay Shore station, Fire Island Ferries, Parking, Suffolk County Parks, Sagtikos Manor, Suffolk County Parks, Gardiner County Park, The Boulton Center (read 7 November 2026).

The cars

Cars for the Ferry Run

Beach weekends mean bags: six guests with six suitcases fit either SUV.

One flat rate: gratuity, tax and card fees included, tolls added before you confirm. No surprises, never surged.

  • Black Cadillac CT4 luxury sedan
    Classic

    Luxury Sedan

    3 seats · 3 suitcases · A 2024 or newer Cadillac, Mercedes-Benz, Lincoln or Lexus, or similar, for airports, meetings and evenings out

  • Black Mercedes-Benz S-Class premium sedan
    Flagship

    Premium Sedan

    3 seats · 3 suitcases · A 2024 or newer Mercedes-Benz S-Class or similar, for executives and special evenings

  • Black Chevrolet Suburban luxury SUV
    Full Luggage

    Luxury SUV

    6 seats · 6 suitcases · A 2024 or newer Chevrolet Suburban, GMC or similar, with room for everyone’s luggage

  • Black Cadillac Escalade premium SUV
    Flagship

    Premium SUV

    6 seats · 6 suitcases · A 2024 or newer Cadillac Escalade or Lincoln Navigator, or similar, the top SUV class for corporate travel

A larger group bound for the ferry travels together in the Executive Sprinter, 14 seats.

Need something different? We build custom prices for groups, events, long trips and company accounts.

Most of our chauffeurs hold a college degree, and every one who drives for Sultan Rides is held to the same standards. Every vehicle carries commercial insurance.

The Sultan Standard

  • Every chauffeur is licensed, insured and background-checked.
  • Your chauffeur wears a black suit and white shirt.
  • Every sedan and SUV is 2024 or newer, with Wi-Fi, premium water and phone chargers on board.
  • Instant online booking, reviewed by a person, at any hour.
  • Your chauffeur’s name, phone number and car reach you before pickup.
  • Discretion is part of the job, whoever is in the back seat.
  • Every chauffeur who drives Sultan Rides trips consents to a confidentiality agreement (NDA) that keeps clients’ names, trip details and anything seen or heard during a ride private.
  • Sedans and SUVs canceled 24+ hours before pickup are refunded less the 4% card fee; under 24 hours, 50% less that fee; no refund once dispatched or no-show.
★★★★★
“Amazing service! Picked me up and drove me to the airport at a timely manner. Everything went smoothly and couldn’t ask for a better ride. Will definitely be my go to when I need a ride!”
Felicia · Google review
★★★★★
“The pick up was punctual. The driver was respectful and the car was clean and comfortable. It was a good experience.”
Norma · Google review

Rated 5.0 on Google · Read the reviews

Top photo: Setting sun over Great South Bay.jpg, Jsayre64, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0).

Questions

Bay Shore and the Ferry, Answered

Reserve online at least 12 hours ahead, or call for anything sooner. Call (917) 720-2726 · Text (917) 672-3790

Can you take me from JFK to the Fire Island ferry in Bay Shore?

Yes, to the dock at 99 Maple Avenue. Google Maps typically showed 55 min–1 h 40 from JFK at 2 p.m. on a Wednesday, about 33 miles.

Which Fire Island towns do the Bay Shore ferries serve?

Kismet, Saltaire, Fair Harbor, Atlantique, Dunewood, Ocean Beach, Seaview and Ocean Bay Park, per Fire Island Ferries.

How long is the ferry from Bay Shore?

Fire Island Ferries calls it a thirty-minute ferry from Bay Shore.

How far is Bay Shore from MacArthur Airport?

About 12 miles from the ferry terminal; Google typically showed 18–22 min at 5 a.m.

How long is Manhattan to the Bay Shore ferry?

Typically 1 h 30–3 h 30 from Times Square at 2 p.m., and 1 h 20–2 h 10 from the dock to Times Square at 2 p.m., by Google Maps.

How much is a car service from Bay Shore to JFK?

Your exact Bay Shore–JFK rate is on the reservation page before you confirm. One flat rate. Gratuity, tax and card fees are included; tolls and congestion pricing for your route are added before you confirm. Meet and greet is available as an add-on. No surprises, never surged.

Can you wait while we catch a later boat?

Yes. Reserve by the hour and the chauffeur stays with you until the boat leaves. One hourly rate, three hours at least: gratuity, tax and card fees included, plus tolls. Never surged.

What if the ferry back to Bay Shore runs late?

Text us when the boat is delayed and we move the pickup. 15 minutes’ grace at non-airport pickups.

Can you bring a child seat to the Bay Shore ferry?

Yes. Ask for one in the reservation and it is installed before the car reaches you.

Is there parking at the Bay Shore ferry?

Fire Island Ferries has lots at its terminals, but says parking fills up fast in the summer season and recommends arriving by public transportation or being dropped off. A chauffeur drop-off at your gate avoids the lot.